An earlier version of this article was donated to Wikipedia
Irish merchant shipping ensured that vital imports continued to arrive and exports, mainly food supplies to Great Britain, were delivered. Irish ships sailed unarmed and usually alone, identifying themselves as neutrals with bright lights and by painting the Irish tricolour and EIRE (note26) in large letters on their sides and decks. (2) Nonetheless twenty percent of seamen serving in Irish ships perished, victims of a war not their own: attacked by both sides, though predominantly by the Axis powers.
SS Irish Poplar
arriving in Dublin during WW II.
Note the clear markings of
“EIRE” and the tricolours.
Photograph courtesy of Rosslare Maritime, original C.J. Buckley, T. Conlan Collection.
Often, Allied convoys could not stop to pick up survivors, (3) (4) (196) while Irish ships always answered SOS signals and stopped to rescue survivors, irrespective of which side they belonged to. Irish ships rescued more than 534 seamen. (note27) (note28) There were never more than 800 men, at any one time, serving on Irish ships during the war. (12)
At the outbreak of World War II, known as “The Emergency”, (note29) Ireland declared neutrality and became isolated as never before. (9) Shipping had been neglected since independence. Foreign ships, on which Ireland’s trade had hitherto depended, were less available; neutral American ships would not enter the “war zone”. In his Saint Patrick’s Day address in 1940, Taoiseach Éamon de Valera lamented:
“No country had ever been more effectively blockaded because of the activities of belligerents and our lack of ships…”
There were three principal trade routes:
- “Cross-channel” trade, between Ireland and Britain, was from both national perspectives, the most important Irish trade route. Ireland was a net food exporter. The excess was shipped to Britain. The Irish Mercantile Marine ensured that Irish agricultural, and other, exports reached Britain, and that British coal and manufactured goods arrived in Ireland.
- Irish ships crossed the Atlantic on a route defined by the Allies: a line from Fastnet Rock to the Azores and then along the line of latitude at 38° North. (10) Although Ireland was a net food exporter, some foods such as wheat, fruits and tea were imported. There was considerable anxiety over the supply of wheat. Wheat, corn as an animal feed and phosphates as fertiliser were imported from North America
- Ships on the “Lisbon-run”, imported wheat, maize as animal food and fruits from Spain and Portugal, as well as goods transhipped from the Americas,
Ireland depended on, mainly, British tankers for petroleum. (note30)
Initially Irish ships sailed in British convoys. In the light of experience they chose to sail alone, relying on their neutral markings. German respect for that neutrality varied from friendly to tragic.
Following independence in 1921, there was no state encouragement to develop the mercantile marine. The Ports and Harbours Tribunal (13) reported “Public Apathy in Port Affairs” (14); “Our new leaders seemed to turn their backs upon the sea and to ignore the fact that we are an island”. The then Taoiseach (Prime Minister) Éamon de Valera had advocated a policy of self-sufficiency. Foreign imports were discouraged. “It was an important status symbol in the modern world for a country to produce her own goods and be self-sufficient.” (24) Each year the fleet declined. In 1923, the merchant fleet consisted of 127 ships. This number dropped every year until 1939 when, at the start of World War II, the fleet numbered only 56 ships. (15) Only 5% of imports were carried on Irish flagged vessels. (16)
There were several reasons for this decline: (17) a consequence of the war of independence, a policy of self-sufficiency, the economic depression, the lack of investment (18) and government neglect. (15A) Foreign ships, on which Ireland had hitherto depended, were withdrawn. “In the period April 1941 and June 1942 only seven such ships visited the country”. (19) The war of independence (1919–1921), and the civil war (1921–1922) which followed it, left the country in near economic collapse. There had been destruction of industry and infrastructure. (20) Many industries relocated abroad. It was often cheaper to transport by sea, within Ireland, rather than using the poor road (21) and rail networks. (22) To take advantage of this commercial opportunity, new coasters (note31) were acquired in the 1930s, intended to ply between Irish ports. These ships would be invaluable once hostilities began. Many of these small coasters were lost, particularly on the “Lisbon run”, a voyage for which they were never intended. (23)
Menapia leaving São Tomé November 1943 with a cargo of palm oil, an 8,000 mile voyage for a 900 GRT ship. (25)Oil by Kenneth King – on display in Straid Studio, Glencolmcille, Donegal
The global economic depression of the early 1930s impacted upon Ireland less because of the partial recovery following the civil war and because industry was protected behind tariff barriers established during the Anglo-Irish Trade War (1932–1938). (note32) The need for extra sea capacity was readily met by British and other foreign ships. Foreign ships were used, rather than preserving the home fleet. Banks were reluctant to lend to Irish industry, (27) preferring British government gilts. (note33) (28).
Although there was state support for many industries, this did not extend to shipping. In 1933 de Valera’s government established the Turf Development Board; turf became Ireland’s primary source of fuel during the emergency years and was stockpiled as imported coal was in short supply. In 1935 civil servants in de Valera’s own department warned him of the consequences a war would have on the importation of fuel. He ignored that warning. (29) Earlier, in 1926 the Ports and Harbours Tribunal was initiated. (30) The tribunal received “abundant evidence” of “inefficient, uneconomic and extravagant management”. (31) It submitted a report in 1930 with recommendations which were not implemented until after the war. The tribunal observed “the public generally do not, we fear, appreciate the importance of our harbours …”. (30A) Vickers-Armstrong liquidated their subsidiary Vickers (Ireland) Ltd. on 15 November 1938; their Dublin Dockyard had ceased operation in 1937. (32)
Seán Lemass as Minister for Industry and Commerce, and later Minister for Supplies sought to address these issues. (38) Many infant industries were developed in the 1930s (39) behind a protective tariff barrier. These industries proved valuable in the war years. They reduced the need for imports, for example in 1931 over five million pairs of shoes were imported, by 1938 this had fallen to a quarter of a million pairs. (24A) Between 1931 and 1938, Gross Industrial Output rose from £55 million to £90 million; and Industrial Employment from 162,000 to 217,000. (41)
Industry lacked finance. In 1933 the government established the Industrial Credit Corporation to provide finance. In 1938, Life Assurers were required to hold their reserves in Ireland, to make capital available for industry; promptly five of the six UK providers closed, (note34) They lodged their business with Irish Assurance. (note35) Private enterprises established included: Grain Importers Ltd., Animal Feed Stuffs Ltd., Fuel Importers Ltd., Oil and Fats Ltd., Timber Importers Ltd., and Tea Importers Ltd. Industries were encouraged. There were plans for Irish National Refineries Ltd. to build an oil refinery. (42) The former Vickers repair yard in Dublin port was reopened, in 1940, by the Dublin Port and Docks Board. It repaired British and Irish ships; (43) Repairing British ships was technically a violation of neutrality and therefore kelp secret. Semi-state enterprises were established, including Irish Shipping in 1941 (note36) (44) which purchased nine vessels and leased six more. (45)
At the outbreak of the Second World War Ireland declared neutrality. (47) There were a total of 56 Irish ships at the outbreak of World War II; 15 more were purchased or leased in the conflict, and 16 were lost. (note37) . All were required by UK law to fly the Red Ensign, but some, such as the Wexford Steamship Company ships, had always travelled under the tricolour. (52) There were instances when Irish captains were fined by British courts for “flying an inappropriate ensign” With the outbreak of hostilities, choices were forced. The Irish government ordered all Irish ships to fly the tricolour. (53)
Some British-owned ships were on the Irish register, such as the whalers which were Scottish-owned (Christian Salvesen Shipping) (54) but Irish-registered (55) in order to take advantage of the Irish whale quota. The six whale catchers and the two factory ships, which were excellent bulk-carriers, were pressed into British naval service. (56) Some ships which could be described as British also choose the Tricolour. Kerrymore, which was registered as belonging to R McGowan of Tralee, was actually owned by Kelly Colliers of Belfast. Most of the crew had addresses in loyalist areas of Belfast. For six years they sailed under the tricolour. (57)
B&I had some of its ships on the British registry with others on the Irish registry. Their MV Munster which operated the Belfast to Liverpool route, (both British ports) flew the tricolour. But, no flag was a protection against mines; Munster struck a mine approaching Liverpool and sank. (note38) Three months earlier, in June 1939, B&I transferred their Normandy Coast from the Irish to the British register. In Dublin, the crew protested and walked off the ship. The management refused to reconsider. On 11 January 1945, U-1055 torpedoed and sank Normandy Coast with the loss of 19 lives; 8 survived.
The L&NWR ferries Cambria, Hibernia and Scotia (note39) were Irish-registered and sailed between Dún Laoghaire and Holyhead. Up to the declaration of war, as was the practice of most Irish ships, they sailed under the Red Ensign. Their British crews were taken aback when the tricolour was hoisted, as Irish law required all irish-registered ships henceforth to fly the tricolour. They went on strike and refused to sail. The management acquisted. The ships were transferred from the Irish registry to the British registry and red ensign restored. (60) (61) Scotia was sunk in the Dunkirk evacuation with the loss of 30 crew and 300 troops. (62) Hibernia had a fortunate escape on the night of 20 December 1940. She was berthing at Dún Laoghaire when a German bomber swooped down. All lights were extinguished. Bombs fell on the nearby Sandycove railway station. (63) The GWR ferries operated the Rosslare to Fishguard route sailed under the red ensign. Thirty lives were lost when their Saint Patrick was bombed and sunk. (64) (65)
Chart illustrating how Irish agriculture
The main export was agricultural produce to Britain. In the First World War, Ireland’s food production increased to meet Britain’s needs; a pattern which would be repeated for the Second World War. In 1916 there were 1,735,000 acres under plough, this increased to 2,383,000 acres in 1918, and then fell back. By the start of the trade war in 1932 tillage had fallen to 1,424,000 acres. (66A)
The trade war between Ireland and Britain started in 1932, in which Britain imposed a tax on Irish products. Cattle from the Irish Republic were taxed but cattle from Northern Ireland were not. So, cattle were smuggled across the border. In 1934/5, about 1,000,000 cattle were “exported” in this way (67). In 1935, Basil Brooke, the Northern Ireland Minister for Agriculture wrote “the smugglers are suceeding”. he was commentating on the number of seized smuggled cattle. The number succcessfully smuggled would have to be multiples of the number seized. in 1933 50,000 were seized and just under 80,000 were seized in 1934 (40) The Department of Supplies was “all in favour of the smuggling and urged that nothing should be done which might stop it”. (68) By then, Britain was anxious to secure Irish food supplies before another world war. (note40) Survival in the looming war was the spur. (70) There were a series of agreements from the “cattle-coal pact” of 1935 to the Anglo-Irish Trade Agreement of 1938 which ended the dispute, on terms favourable to Ireland. (71)
|Beef, thousand tons||0.0||1.0||0.3||16.2||5.7||1.0||3.1||3.9|
There was an outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease in 1941. (72)
For some months the export and movement of live cattle was prohibited. (73)
The drop in numbers in 1943 may be the result of smuggling
Under the “cattle-coal pact”, (74) the British set up a central authority for the purchase of cattle, under John Maynard Keynes. (75) The prices set before the war were attractive. As the war progressed, open market prices rose dramatically. (76) (77) Cattle from Northern Ireland fetched a better price, so smuggling, as practised in the trade war, resumed. (note41) In answer to the demand for food in World War II, the area under plough increased from 1,492,000 acres in 1939 to 2,567,000 acres in 1944. (66B) Studies are inconclusive on how vital Irish food exports were to Britain, (79) due to the difficulties in accounting for the effect of smuggling, (80) the unreliability of statistics, (81) and wartime censorship. (82) While Ireland’s food production was increasing, British food imports were falling; for example the UK imported 1,360,000 tons of food in August 1941, but only 674,000 tons in August 1942. (83)
Irish food consumption remained high in World War II
Before, during and after the second world war, Ireland was a net food exporter and the Irish people enjoyed a high calorie diet. (84A) (Nonetheless the poor experienced real deprivation). Food was donated to war-refugees in Spain. (85) The nation did need to import certain foods, such as fruits, tea and wheat. Nearly half of Ireland’s wheat was imported from Canada. (86) Domestic food production relied on imported fertilizer (note42) and imported animal feeding stuffs. In 1940, 74,000 tons (note43) of fertilizer were imported, only 7,000 tons arrived in 1941. Similarly 5 million tons of animal feed were imported in 1940, falling to one million in 1941 and negligible quantities thereafter. (88)
Although Ireland had a surplus of food, some foods were not grown in Ireland, as the climate was unsuitable. Only small plots of wheat were cultivated. A series of orders for compulsory tillage were enacted, (0) (note44) with the threat that those who did not put their fields to wheat would have their land confiscated. (91) In 1939, 235,000 acres of wheat were planted; by 1945 this had increased to 662,000 acres. (92) Yet, a shortfall remained and imports were required. Clashes between smugglers and Customs were commonplace.
In 1940 the infamous “Battle of Dowra” took place on the border of Leitrim and Fermanagh. Revenue crews from Blacklion and Glenfarne intercepted over a hundred men with donkey loads of smuggled flour. Unwilling to part with their bounty, the smugglers used cudgels, boots, stones and fists in the ensuing struggle. Most of the flour was destroyed in the fray and some Revenue people were injured. (93) (37)
News of the threat to Guinness supplies was censored. But these advertisements appeared shortly afterwards
Early in 1942, the Allies restricted wheat deliveries to Ireland. In return, the Irish threatened to withhold the export of Guinness beer. (94) (95) To the great annoyance of David Gray, the United States Ambassador to Ireland, (note45) Ireland received 30,000 tons of wheat. (96) Gray complained of a waste of “a vital necessity for what Americans regard at the best as a luxury and at worst a poison”. (94A)
By 1944–45 coal imports were only one-third of those of 1938-9 and supplies of oil had almost ceased. The production of town gas, manufactured from imported coal, was so adversely affected that regulations were brought in limiting its use, enforced by the “Glimmer Man”. (97) Britain relaxed these restrictions from 19 July 1944. (98)
There were plans to build an oil refinery in Dublin. (note46) In the event, this refinery was not completed. (99) Nonetheless seven oil tankers were built in Bremen-Vegesack, Germany for Inver Tankers Ltd. Each 500 feet (150 m) long and capable of carrying 500 tons were on the Irish register. (100) Britain asked Ireland to requisition the tankers, (101) The reply was that it was not Irish policy to requisition vessels, instead offering to transfer them to the British register. (102) They were transferred on the 6th, war had been declared on the 3rd. (103) (note47) (102A)
“In a manner reminiscent of Chamberlain’s handover of the ports to de Valera, two days after the outbreak of war, de Valera himself transferred the tankers to the British registry without getting any promise of fuel supply in return. (104) (105) (note48) (106)”
Two days after the transfer, on 11 September 1939, while still flying the Irish tricolour, Inverliffey was sunk. (103A) In spite of Captain William Trowsdale’s protestation that they were Irish and therefore neutal, U-38 said that they “were sorry” but they would sink Inverliffey as she was carrying petrol to England, considered contraband by the Germans. (note49) (110) U-38’s next encounter with the Irish tricolour was less gallant. U-38 shelled the fishing trawler Leukos, all 11 crew were lost. Inver Tankers’ entire fleet was lost in the war. (note50) (note51) (114) (note52) (116)
Vizeadmiral Karl Dönitz issued a standing order to U-boats on 4 September 1940, which defined belligerent, neutral and friendly powers. Neutral included “Ireland in particular”. The order concluded: “Ireland forbids the navigation of her territorial waters by warships under threat of internment. That prohibition is to be strictly observed out of consideration for the proper preservation of her neutrality. Signed, Dönitz”. (117) However those orders did not always protect Irish ships. Wolf Jeschonnek, commander of U-607 was mildly reprimanded “An understandable mistake by an eager captain” for sinking Irish Oak. (118) When U-46 sank Luimneach on the Lisbon run, her commander recorded in his war diary “flying a British or Irish flag”. (119) A supplement to Dönitz’s order found after U-260 was scuttled off Cork (120) read: “for political reasons, Irish ships and also at times Irish convoys are not to be attacked within the blockade zone if they are seen to be such. However, there is no special obligation to determine neutrality in the blockade zone.”. (121)
Oil painting by Kenneth King: from the deck of U-753, signalling to Irish Willow “send master and ships papers” (National Maritime Museum of Ireland)
There were many encounters with U-boats, some pleasant, others not so. On 16 March 1942 Irish Willow was stopped by U-753, (122) which signalled “Send master and ship’s papers”. As Capt Shanks hailed from Belfast and therefore legally a British subject, this was considered unwise. Chief Officer Harry Cullen and four crew rowed to the U-boat. He said that his (39-year-old) captain was too elderly for the boat. He added that it would be Saint Patrick’s Day in the morning. To celebrate the occassion, they were treated to schnapps in the conning tower and given a bottle of cognac to bring back to the crew of the Irish Willow. (123) On a later voyage Irish Willow performed a dangerous rescue of 47 British sailors from Empire Breeze. (note53) (124) (note54)
On 20 March 1943 U-638, commanded by Kapitänleutnant Heinrich Oskar Bernbeck stopped Irish Elm. Rough seas prevented Elm’s crew from pulling their rowboat alongside the submarine to present their papers, so the interview was conducted by shouting. In the course of the conversation, Elm’s Chief Officer Patrick Hennessy gave Dún Laoghaire as his home address. Bernbeck asked if “the strike was still on in Downey’s?”, (125) a pub near Dún Laoghaire harbour. (The Downey’s strike started in March 1939 and lasted 14 years). (126))
Oil painting by Kenneth King:22 October 1940, Kerry Head left Limerick exporting food to Newport Monmouthshire, The Luftwaffe attacked when she was five miles west of Sheep’s Head. It was a direct hit. Kerry Head sank immediately. All died. No bodies were ever recovered
The Irish and British authorities co-operated in the chartering of ships. They made combined purchases of wheat, maize, sugar, animal feeds and petrol. (79A)
At the start of the war, Irish ships sailed in convoys protected by the Royal Navy. The advantages were protection and insurance. These advantages were not borne out by experience. So they chose to sail alone. (127) Insurers such as Lloyd’s of London charged a higher premium to insure ships not in convoy, or refused insurance. So ship-owners instructed their ships to accept the British offer of Royal Navy protection. Events caused them to review the value of insurance and the ability of the Roal Navy to protect them.
The value of insurance was reviewed after the failure of the life insurance claim following the loss of City of Waterford. When she joined Convoy OG 74, the lives of the crew were insured. The ship suffered a collision with the Dutch tugboat Thames, and sank. Waterford’s crew were taken aboard by HMS Deptford and then transferred to the rescue ship Walmer Castle. (128) Walmer Castle was bombed two days later (129) and five of City of Waterford’s survivors were killed. When their families made life insurance claims, they were refused, because at their time of death they were not crew of City of Waterford, but passengers of Walmer Castle. (130) Later the Irish government introduced a compensation scheme for seamen lost or injured on Irish ships (131) and Irish Shipping opened its own marine insurance subsidiary, which made a handsome profit. (132) (note55)
The ability of the Royal Navy to protect was questioned after the losses suffered in convoy OG-71, known as “nightmare convoy” (133). Two Limerick Steamship Company ships, Lanahrone and Clonlara were part of convoy” OG 71, which left Liverpool on 13 August 1941. (134) bound for Gibralter. On 19 August in separate attacks the Norwegian destroyer HNoMS Bath was drawn away from the convoy and sunk by U-204, (136) and three minutes later U-559 sank the British merchant ship Alva. (0) (138) The Limerick ship Clonlara rescued 13 survivors from Alva. (139) Two hours later U-201 sank the Commodore ship Aguila (140) and the British cargo ship Ciscar. (141) The convoy was subjected to continous attack. U-564 sank Clonlara. (142) The corvette HMS Campion rescued 13 survivors (eight from Clonlara and five from Alva). In all, eight merchant ships, (0) two naval escorts and over 400 lives were lost, (note56) (143) when the decision was taken to retreat to neutral Lisbon. Five of the convoy’s surviving merchant ships reached Gibraltar; 10 retreated to neutral Portugal. (134A) (144) This was described as “a bitter act of surrender as could ever come our way”. (145) The City of Dublin had arrived in Lisbon earlier with the new crew of the Irish Poplar. The two Irish crews saw the sad remneants of OG-71 limp in. Lanahrone’s crew initially refused to return in convoy and went on strike, which was resolved with extra life-rafts and pay; Lanahrone returned in Convoy HG 73. Nine of the 25 ships in that convoy were lost. (0) The crew of Irish Poplar resolved to sail home alone. (147) Captain Matthew Moran cabled Irish Shipping to say that they would travel alone. While City of Dublin brought Clonlara’s survivors to Cork, These experiences of the inability of the Royal Navy to protect merchant ships had a most profound effect on all Irish Ships. Ship-owners, on the advice of their masters, decided not to sail their vessels in convoys and by the early months of 1942 the practice had ceased. (148)
Captain William Henderson of Irish Elm, returning from a transatlantic voyage reported “circled by two German bombers, probably Condors, they circled for a considerable time and inspected closely but didn’t molest. The incident had given the crew great confidence in the protection afforded by the neutral markings”. (149) However there were many instances when those markings were not respected.
This “cross-channel” trade accounted for most (note57) of Ireland’s trade. (150) The ships ranged, in age, from Dundalk built, two years before the start of the war, in 1937 to Brooklands built in 1859. (61A) The most important vessels to Ireland were the ten colliers and to Britain the livestock carriers. (74A) Initially Germany respected the neutrality of Irish vessels, apologising for the first attack on the collier Kerry Head and paying compensation. (58) Losses came from mines, rather than direct attacks. Meath suffered such a fate; while she was being inspected by the British Naval Control Service, she was struck by a magnetic mine, drowning seven hundred cattle, and destroying both vessels. (151)
In August 1940 Germany “required” Ireland to cease food exports to Britain. (152) Ireland failed to comply. On 17 August 1940, Germany declared a large area around Britain to be a “scene of warlike operations”. (153) It was believed that attacks on Irish ships and the bombing of Campile was to reinforce that message. (154) Lord Haw-Haw in a broadcast on German radio, threatened that Dundalk would be bombed if the export of cattle to Britain continued. (155) On 24 July 1941, George’s Quay, Dundalk was bombed. (156) Nonetheless, the trade continued.
The first attack, after the German ultimatum, was against the schooner Lock Ryan, returning to Arklow. She was strafed and bombed by three German aircraft. Fortunately Lock Ryan’s cargo of china clay absorbed the blast and although badly damaged, she survived. Germany acknowledged the attack but refused to pay compensation for the damage as she was in “the blockaded area”, (157) “through which the Irish had been offered free passage but on terms which were rejected”. (158) There were many attacks on ships on the cross-channel trade. In 1940 nine Irish ships were lost. (note58) That figure may be small compared with Allied losses, but it represents a larger proportion of the small Irish fleet. (53A) There were restrictions on reporting attacks on ships. Frank Aiken, the government minister whose responsibilities included censorship, reverted this policy when the collier Glencree was strafed. (163) His intention was to let Germany know that the Irish public know, and “they don’t like it”. (158A) There had been an Allied proposal for transshipment. (note59) William Warnock, the Irish chargé d’affaires in Berlin told Germany that Ireland was refusing to transship British cargoes, (160) while protesting against the attacks on Irish ships, and other neutral ships with Irish cargoes. (161) Deliberate attacks on cross-channel shipping ceased on 5 November 1941, (162) (note60) (note61) There were attacks on other routes. Mines were a constant danger.
The City of Limerick was bombed and sunk on 15 July 1940 in the Bay of Biscay while on the “Lisbon Run”, with a cargo of fruit, en route to Liverpool for inspection. Ship and two crew were lost.
Oil painting by Kenneth King
on display in the National Maritime Museum
The Iberian trade
On November 1939, Roosevelt signed the Fourth Neutrality Act forbidding American ships from entering the “war zone”, (164) which was defined as a line drawn from Spain to Iceland. Cargoes intended for Ireland were shipped to Portugal. It was up to the Irish to fetch them from there. (165) This route, known as the “Iberian Trade” or the “Lisbon run”. Setting sail from Ireland the ships carried agricultural products to the United Kingdom. There they would discharge their cargo, load up a British export (often coal) (note62) , refuel and carry it to Portugal. (48) In Portugal, usually Lisbon, Irish ships delivered the British export (174) and loaded the waiting American cargo, such as fertilizer or agricultural machinery.
Sometimes the cargo was not there: it may have been delayed, or lost at sea due to the war. In this case, the Irish captains would load a “cargo of opportunity” and bring it back to Ireland. This might be wheat or oranges; on occasions, they even purchased the cargo of coal on their own ship. MV Kerlogue was fortunate to have a cargo of coal when two unidentified aircraft attacked her with cannon fire. The shells lodged in the coal, rather than piercing her hull. (166) Britain denied involvement, but when the coal was discharged shell fragments of British manufacture were found. The attackers were de Havilland Mosquitos of the Polish squadron of the RAF. (note63)
Other Irish ships were was not so fortunate. Cymric vanished in the same waters without a trace.
The Lisbon run was undertaken by small coastal trading vessels, commonly called coasters, which were not designed for deep-sea navigation. (48A) Small, and having low freeboard (frequently around one foot) these ships were designed never to be out of sight of land, and to be able to make quickly to a harbour when the weather turned foul. Kerlogue has become the exemplar of the Irish Mercantile Marine in the Emergency. Only 335 gross register tons (GRT) and 142 feet long, Kerlogue was attacked by both sides (169) and rescued both sides. Her rescue of 168 German sailors, (170) given her size, was dramatic.
From January 1941, British authorities required Irish ships to visit a British port and obtain a “navicert”. (171) This visit sometimes proved fatal. (172) It also added up to 1,300 miles to the voyage. (173) A ship with a “navicert” was given free passage through allied patrols and fuel, (104A) however they would be searched.
Oil painting of SS Irish Poplar, by artist Kenneth King courtesy of Cormac Lowth.
Some British ships traded between Ireland and Britain. Other destinations were served by Irish and other neutral ships. Philip Noel-Baker (Churchill’s Parliamentary Secretary) was able to tell the British parliament that “no United Kingdom or Allied ship has been lost while carrying a full cargo of goods either to or from Eire on an ocean voyage.” (175) He added “a very high proportion of imports from overseas sources into Eire, and of such exports as are sent overseas from Eire, are already carried in ships on the Eire or on a neutral register.” and “The trade between Great Britain and Eire is of mutual benefit to both countries, and the risks to British seamen which it involves are small.” (175A)
In the economic depression of the 1930s, the Limerick Steamship Company sold both its ocean-going ships, Knockfierna and Kilcredane. (165A) They were Ireland’s last ocean-going ships. At the outbreak of hostilities Ireland did not have a ship designed to cross the Atlantic. British ships were not available. American ships would only travel to Portugal. Ireland depended on other neutrals. In 1940 a succession of these ships, from Norway, (note64) Greece, (note65) Argentina, (note66) (178) and Finland, (note67) (179) usually carrying wheat to Ireland, were lost. Soon many of these nations were no longer neutral. Ireland had to acquire its own fleet. Irish Shipping was formed. Irish Poplar was Irish Shipping’s first ship. It was acquired in Spain after it had been abandoned by its crew. (44A) Other ships were acquired from Palestine, Panama, Jugoslavia (note68) , and Chile. The Irish government minister Frank Aiken negotiated the bareboat chartering of two oil-burning steamships from the United States Maritime Commission’s reserve fleet. (180) They were both lost to U-boats. Irish Oak was sunk in controversial circumstances by U-607. All 33 crew of Irish Pine were lost when she was sunk by U-608. Three ships were from Estonia, They were in Irish ports when Estonia was annexed by the Soviet Union. Their crews refused to return to the new Estonian SSR. The ships were sold to Irish Shipping. (note69) (181) (182) The SS Cetvrti (Jugoslavia) was abandoned in Dingle Bay after being strafed on 1 December 1940. She was salvaged by Fort Rannoch of the Irish Navy; she was purchased and renamed Irish Beech. (183) An Italian ship, Caterina Gerolimich had been trapped in Dublin since the outbreak of the war. After the fall of Italian Fascism she was chartered, repaired and renamed Irish Cedar. When the war was over, she returned to Naples with a cargo of food, a gift from Ireland to war-ravaged Italy. Irish Hazel was bought on 17 June 1941. She was 46 years old, and required extensive repairs. “She was fit for nothing but the scrap yard.” (184) A British yard bid for, and won, the contract to renovate her. This work was completed in November 1943. Even though the Irish government paid for her purchase and for the repairs she was requisitioned by the British Ministry of War Transport and renamed Empire Don. (note70) .The Irish Shipping fleet imported, across the Atlantic: 712,000 tons of wheat, 178,000 tons of coal, 63,000 tons of phosphate (for fertilizer), 24,000 tons of tobacco, 19,000 tons of newsprint, 10,000 tons of timber and 105,000 tons of assorted other cargo. (187)
After the war
When the hostilities were over, on 16 May 1945, Éamon de Valera, in his speech to the nation said: “To the men of our Mercantile Marine who faced all the perils of the ocean to bring us essential supplies, the nation is profoundly grateful.” (189) The Ringsend area of Dublin has a long maritime tradition. When housing was being redeveloped in the 1970s, some streets were named after ships which were lost: Breman Road, Breman Grove, Cymric Road, Isolda Road, Pine Road, Leukos Road, Kyleclare Road and Clonlara Road. The “An Bonn Seirbhíse Éigeandála” for “An tSeirbhís Mhuir-Thráchtála” or in English: “Emergency Service Medal” of the “Mercantile Marine Service”,was awarded to all who had served six months, or longer, on an Irish-registered ship in the Emergency. (190)
On 24 September 2001, a plinth and plaque, embossed with the Irish tricolour was erected to commemorate those crews lost on neutral Irish registered vessels in 1939-45. “a very significant gesture by our British friends towards recognising the debt of honour owed to all shipmates irrespective of nationality who lost their lives in the Second World War.” (191) in the National Memorial Arboretum in England. (192) In Dublin, an annual commemoration, is held on the third Sunday of November. The Cork commemoration is held on the fourth Sunday of November in the former offices of the White Star Line. The Belfast commemoration is held on the second Sunday of May.
- note 1 ^^ lost with all hands 24 Feb 1944
- note 2 ^^ Liverpool Maritime Museum
- note 3 ^^ featured in the film Moby Dick
- note 4 ^^ featured in the film Moby Dick
- note 5 ^^ Was a Q-ship in WW1. Later starred in several films. 20 Dec 1944 wrecked during a storm in the Solway Firth.
- note 6 ^^ 11 November 1940, struck a mine near the Saltees, 24 died
- note 7 ^^ 21 December 1940, leaving Liverpool with 220 passengers and crew, struck a mine off New Brighton and sank. Four died.
- note 8 ^^ The B & I Line had other ships on the British registry and are not discussed in this article.
- note 9 ^^ 16 August 1940, struck a mine and sank, all survived
- note 10 ^^ 2 February 1940 on entering Liverpool Bay with over 250 passengers and crew, struck a mine and sank, all survived
- note 11 ^^ 22 March 1941, the collier Saint Fintan was sailing from Drogheda to Cardiff, she was bombed by the Luftwaffe off the coast of Pembrookshire and sank with all hands. Nine died
- note 12 ^^ 15 May 1943 torpedoed by U-607 and sank. Crew rescued twelve hours later by Irish Plane
- note 13 ^^ 15 November 1942 torpedoed and sunk by U-608 with all hands. 33 died
- note 14 ^^ was in convoy OG71, known as “Nightmare Convoy”, when on 22 August 1941 she was torpedoed and sunk by U564. 11 died, 13 survived
- note 15 ^^ 23 February 1943, torpedoed and sunk by U456 while importing wheat from Lisbon for Dublin. All 18 crew lost.
- note 16 ^^ 4 September 1940 sunk by gunfire from U46 crew survived
- note 17 ^^ 4 January 1940 struck rocks near Cape Clear and was lost.
- note 18 ^^ 21 January 1940 groundfed and lost on the Goodwin Sands.
- note 19 ^^ 2 June 1942 sunk by gunfire from U46 crew survived
- note 20 ^^ 15 July 1940 bombed and sunk. Two crew died.
- note 21 ^^ 19 September 1941 while in convoy OG74 she was accidentally rammed and sunk by the Dutch tug Thames. click here to read more
- note 22 ^^ 22 Oct 1940 bombed and sunk off Cape Clear Island, all 12 crew died.
- note 23 ^^ 7 March 1942 wrecked in a storm off Donegal
- note 24 ^^ 17 September 1941 while trying to avoid mines she grounded on a sandbank in the Bristol Channell and was wrecked
- note 25 ^^ In Ireland it is the “Mercantile Marine”; in the United Kingdom, it is the “Merchant Navy”; in the USA, it is the “Merchant Marine”.
- note 26 ^^ Éire is the Irish name for Ireland. From 1937 “Ireland” was the correct name for the country. Prior to that it was the “Irish Free State”. British documents of the time, tended to use the word “Eire” while the USA used “Irish Republic”. Churchill said “Southern Ireland”.
- note 27 ^^ At least 534 lives were saved by Irish ships, this excludes rescues by lifeboats, fishing trawlers and other craft. It also excludes transfers, such as on 3 September 1939, the day war was declared, U-30 sank the liner Athenia with 1,103 passengers aboard. 430 survivors were rescued by the Norwegian Knute Nelson. They were transferred to the Irish Cathair na Gaillimhe and brought to Galway. They were met by a group sent by the American ambassador London to assist Americans. This group included his son, John Fitzgerald Kennedy.
- note 28 ^^ Most sources say 521. 5 This comes from a list of rescues in Appendix 4 of Frank Forde’s book The Long Watch. 6 However that list is incomplete, it omits the rescue of 13 survivors from Roxby by Irish Beech. 7
- note 29 ^^ “The Emergency” was an official euphemism used by the Irish Government to refer to World War II.
- note 30 ^^ As the Dublin registered Inver tanker fleet had been transferred to the British register.
- note 31 ^^ Coaster: as the name implies, these ships were suited to travelling close to shore, between ports on the same island. They were suited for shallow waters, unsuited for the oceans. The assumption was that if a storm threatened they could promptly reach the safety of a harbour.
- note 32 ^^ In their election manifesto in 1948 Fianna Fáil claimed to have established 100 new industries and 900 factories.
- note 33 ^^ The government set up the “Commission of Inquiry into Banking, Currency and Credit”
- note 34 ^^ The five were: Prudential, Britannic, Liverpool Victoria Friendly Society, Pearl, and Refuge; The Royal Liver remained.
- note 35 ^^ As a consequence of the great depression, life assurers went technically insolvent. These companies were: City of Dublin Assurance Company, Irish Life and General Assurance Company, Irish National Assurance Company, and Munster and Leinster Assurance Company. The government merged these.
- note 36 ^^ Irish Shipping was initially 51% government owned
- note 37 ^^ Up to then most Irish-registered ships had been flying the red ensign of the United Kingdom Merchant Navy
- note 38 ^^ There were over 200 passengers and 50 crew on board. A few hours later they were all rescued by the collier Ringwall. 46 Four were injured; and one died later. 58
- note 39 ^^ Anglia was withdrawn in 1935 59
- note 40 ^^ “Ireland did actually have the British over a barrel for a very simple reason – there was going to be a very large war in Europe and it was also evident from the First World War experience that there was a huge danger of Britain and Ireland being cut off from food supplies overseas”. 69
- note 41 ^^ Cattle numbers peaked at 4,246,000 in 1944 78 yet consumption remained level and official exports fell
- note 42 ^^ In June 1942 Lemass told the Dáil that there were only 42,000 acres under sugar beet, as against 73,000 in 1941; this was due to the shortage of artificial fertilizer 87
- note 43 ^^ At this time, in Ireland, imperial tons (also called long ton) were used, that is 1 ton = 2,240 pounds, or 1,016 kilograms
- note 44 ^^ at least 12.5% of all holdings over 10 acres would have to be made available for tillage
- note 45 ^^ David Gray was not titled “ambassador”, but “Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary”.
- note 46 ^^ The Oil Refinery was to be built on right side Alexandra Rd. going towards ferry port, beyond ocean pier
- note 47 ^^ (from Admiralty archives) “The Eire government attached no conditions of any kind to the transfer of flag and were most helpful and gave every assistance in securing the use of the ships for His Majesty’s government”
- note 48 ^^ Dwyer says that there was an agreement, but Britain violated it
- note 49 ^^ The crew took to the lifeboats. Inverliffey burned fiercely, endangering the lifeboats. At risk to herself, U-38 approached and threw lines to the lifeboats and towed them to safety. 107 As Captain Trowsdale’s lifeboat was damaged, they were allowed to board the U-boat. The captain did not have a lifebelt, so he was given one. The crew were transferred to the neutral American tanker R.G. Stewart. 108 109Neither Inverliffey nor U-38 would have been aware of the registry change. 103 In a later voyage U-38 landed Walter Simon, alias “Karl Anderson”,a Nazi agent, at Dingle Bay in Ireland on the night of 12 June 1940. He was promptly arrested.
- note 50 ^^ These tankers, because of their cargo, were highly combustible when attacked. Inversuir was in ballast (empty) when torpedoed by U-48, which then surfaced and fired 51 rounds from the deck gun, without sinking her. Three hours later U-48 fired another torpedo and left, leaving Inversuir still afloat. The next night she was sunk by U-75 111
- note 51 ^^ Inverlane became a popular dive site 112 113 She was still visible above the water until a storm on 29 January 2000, Inverlane finally sank below the waves.
- note 52 ^^ Inverdargle hit a mine laid by U-32, 115Inverilen, Inverlee, and Invershannon were torpedoed.
- note 53 ^^ Empire Breeze, a British ship, was in convoy ON-122 with fog closing in, when she was torpedoed by both U-176 and U-438
- note 54 ^^ the rest of the convoy ON-122 sailed on, as nine u-boats were stalking them. Irish Willow answered the SOS. She was in danger of collision because of the dense fog. 47 crew of Empire Breeze were rescued; one was lost.
- note 55 ^^ After the war Irish Shipping floated off the insurance subsidiary as the Insurance Corporation of Ireland. Much later it was taken over by Allied Irish Banks. After some ill-advised decisions, it had to be rescued by the state and eventually liquidated.
- note 56 ^^ Over 400 were lost, including 152 from the commodore ship Aguila. They included the 22 “lost wrens” who were en route to Gibraltar.
- note 57 ^^ Britain accounted for half of imports and almost all exports, see www.cso.ie
- note 58 ^^ February 2: Munster; 9 March: Leukos; 15 July: City of Limerick; 15 August: Meath; 22 October: Kerry Head; 11 November: Ardmore ; 19 December: Isolda; 21 December: Innisfallen.
- note 59 ^^ The transhipment proposal was for British north-American convoys to terminate at ports in the west of Ireland and their cargo transported overland to ports on Ireland’s east coast for onward shipment to Britain. Lemass had proposed the idea well before the war, but it would require a very large investment in infrastructure. 159Ireland’s transport infrastructure was woefully inadequate.
- note 60 ^^ The rejection of transshipment might have been why these deliberate attacks ceased. Alternatively, this cessation could have been because Germany put a higher priority on attacking convoys bound for Malta or Murmansk
- note 61 ^^ A later loss was from “natural causes”, Lock Ryan was wrecked in a storm, on 7 March 1942.
- note 62 ^^ this earned foreign currency which Britian needed for the war
- note 63 ^^ The British Naval Attaché in Dublin reported to the Director of Naval Intelligence that it was “unfortunate from a British point of view” that Fortune (Captain of Kerlogue) had been involved in the Kerlogue incident as he was “always ready to pass on any information in his possession”. 166 In a damning indictment an Admiralty official concluded “there was nothing very suspicious about the ship and anyone but Polish pilots would have hesitated to attack without inquiring at base”. 167
- note 64 ^^ 17 January 1940 Enid (Captain Wibe) of neutral Norway sailing from Steinkjer to Dublin, 10 miles north of Shetland, went to assist SS Polzella (British) which had been torpedoed by German submarine U-25, U-25 then shelled and sank Enid. Enid’s crew survived. Polzella’s crew were lost. 176
- note 65 ^^ 10 June 1940, Violando N Goulandris of then-neutral Greece sailing from Santa Fe to Waterford with a cargo of wheat was torpedoed by U-48 off Cape Finisterre 6 died 22 survived. 177
- note 66 ^^ 27 May 1940, Uruguay of neutral Argentina sailing from Rosario to Limerick with 6,000 tons of maize, sunk by scuttling charges by U-37 160 miles from Cape Villano, Costa da Morte, Spain 43.40°N 12.16°W. 15 died, 13 survived.
- note 67 ^^ 10 July 1940: Petsamo of Finland, inward Rosario to Cork with a cargo of maize, torpedoed and sunk by U-34, four died
- note 68 ^^ Yugoslavia
- note 69 ^^ 44. • A Soviet claim to the ownership of these vessels was rejected by the Supreme Court … … did not recognize the Government of the USSR as the sovereign government of Latvia and Estonia.
Books, Journals and web-sites consulted
- Anderson, Ernest, Sailing Ships of Ireland (1951) DuMorris
- Barton, Brian, Northern Ireland in the Second World War (1995) page:Belfast: Ulster Historical Foundation ISBN:978-0-901905-69-7.
- Bell, Jonathan; Watson, Mervyn, A History of Irish Farming 1750-1950 (2008) page:Dublin: Four Courts Press ISBN:978-1-84682-096-0.
- Blair, Clay, Hitler’s U-Boat War. London Weidenfeld & Nicolson ISBN:0-297-84076-2.
- Burne, Lester H; Dean Burns, Richard, (eds.), Chronological History of U.S. Foreign Relations: 1932-1988 Routledge ISBN:978-0-415-93916-4.
- Carroll, Joseph T, Ireland in the war years International Scholars Publications ISBN:978-1-57309-186-2.
- Coogan, Tim Pat, De Valera page:London: Arrow Books ISBN:0-09-995860-0.
- Coogan, Tim Pat, Ireland in the Twentieth Century page:London: Hutchinson ISBN:0-09-179427-7.
- Duggan, John P, Neutral Ireland and the Third Reich (1985) Gill and Macmillan ISBN:978-0-389-20598-2.
- Duggan, John P, Herr Hempel Irish Academic Press ISBN:0-7165-2757-X.
- Dwyer, T Ryle, De Valera’s Finest Hour page:Cork: Mercier Press ISBN:0-85342-675-9.
- Dwyer, T Ryle, Strained relations: Ireland at peace and the USA at war, 1941-45 Rowman & Littlefield ISBN:978-0-7171-1580-8.
- Dwyer, T Ryle, Irish neutrality and the USA, 1939-47 (1977) Gill and Macmillan ISBN:978-0-87471-994-9.
- Dwyer, T Ryle, Behind the Green Curtain - Ireland’s Phoney Neutrality During World War II page:Dublin: Gill and Macmillan, ISBN:978-0-7171-4638-3.
- Ferriter, Diarmaid , Judging DeV page:Dublin: Royal Irish Academy ISBN:978-1-904890-28-7.
- Ferriter, Diarmaid, What If? Alternative Views of Twentieth-Century Ireland Gill & Macmillan ISBN:978-0-7171-3990-3.
- Fisk, Robert, In Time of War page:(Later republished as:In Time of War: Ireland, Ulster and the Price of Neutrality, 1939-45: page:London: Gill & Macmillan Ltd ISBN:978-0-7171-2411-4.
- Fitzgerald, John, Are We Invaded Yet? page:Cork: Callan Press
- Forde, Frank, Maritime Arklow (”2000) page:Dún Laoghaire: Glendale Press ISBN:0-907606-51-2.
- Gerwarth, Robert, Twisted paths: Europe 1914-1945 Oxford University Press ISBN:978-0-19-928185-5.
- Gilligan, H.A, A History of the Port of Dublin page:Dublin: Gill and Macmillan ISBN:0-7171-1578-X.
- Gleichauf, Justin, Unsung Sailors Bluejacket Books ISBN:978-1-55750-420-3.
- Gray, Tony, The Lost Years (1997) page:London: Little Brown and Company ISBN:0-316-88189-9.
- Griven, Brian, The Emergency page:London: Macmillan ISBN:978-1-4050-0010-9.
- Johnston, Roy, Century of Endeavour. Irish research series 46 Academica Press ISBN:978-1-930901-76-6.
- Kennedy, Michael, Guarding Neutral Ireland, page:Dublin: Four Courts Press ISBN:978-1-84682-097-7.
- Lee, Joseph, Ireland 1912-1985 Cambridge University Press ISBN:9780521377416.
- Lund, Paul; Ludlam, Harry; Shuttleworth, Tom, Nightmare Convoy Foulsham ISBN:978-0-572-01452-0.
- MacAonghusa, Proinsias, Quotations from Eamon de Valera, page:Dublin: Mercier Press ISBN:0-85342-684-8.
- MacGinty, Tom, The Irish Navy page:Tralee: The Kerryman ISBN:0-946277-22-2.
- Manning, Maurice, Blueshirts (1971) University of Toronto Press ISBN:978-0-8020-1787-1.
- Mason, Ursula, Britannia’s daughters: the story of the WRNS page:Barnsley: Leo Cooper ISBN:978-0-85052-271-6.
- McIvor, Aidan, A History of the Irish Naval Service page:Dublin: Irish Academic Press ISBN:0-7165-2523-2.
- McMahon, Sean, Bombs over Dublin page:Dublin: Currach Press ISBN:978-1-85607-983-9.
- McRonald, Malcolm, The Irish Boats. Volume 3, Liverpool to Belfast Tempus ISBN:978-0-7524-4235-8.
- Monsarrat, Nicholas, Life is a Four Letter Word page:London: Cassell ISBN:978-0-330-02294-1.
- O’Carroll, John P,(ed.), De Valera and his times page:Murphy, John A: Cork University Press, ISBN:0-902561-26-X.
- O’Connell, Cathal, The State and Housing in Ireland Nova Science Publishers Inc, ISBN:978-1-60021-759-3.
- Ó Gráda, Cormac, A rocky road: the Irish economy since the 1920s. Insights from Economic History (1997) page:Manchester: Manchester University Press ISBN:978-0-7190-4584-4.
- Ó Drisceoil, Donal, Censorship in Ireland, 1939-1945 Cork University Press ISBN:978-1-85918-074-7.
- O’Halpin, Eunan, Spying on Ireland page:Oxford: Oxford University Press ISBN:978-0-19-925329-6.
- O’Hanlon (Chairman), H.B.;, Ports and Harbours Tribunal (1930). Report of the Ports and Harbours Tribunal page:Dublin: Government Publications Sales Office
- Raymond, Raymond James, page:In J.P. O’Carroll and John A. Murphy. De Valera and His Times: page:Cork: Cork University Press, ISBN:0-902561-26-X.
- Rohwer, Jürgen, Axis submarine successes of World War Two page:Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press, ISBN:9781853673405.
- Share, Bernard, The Emergency page:Dublin: Gill and Macmillan ISBN:071710916X.
- Sinclair, Andrew, Blood & Kin: an empire saga Sinclair-Stevenson ISBN:978-0-9540476-3-4.
- Somerville-Large, Peter, Irish voices: an informal history Pimlico ISBN:978-0-7126-6532-2.
- Spong, H.C., Irish Shipping Ltd., 1941-1982 World Ship Society ISBN:978-0-905617-20-6.
- Stephan, Enno, Spies in Ireland, (1965) page:London: Four Square
- Sweeney, Pat, Liffey Ships Mercier ISBN:978-1-85635-685-5.
- Warner, Mildred W. Lloyd Warner:, Social Anthropologist Publishing Center for Cultural Resources ISBN:978-0-89062-234-6.
- Walling, Michael G, Bloodstained Sea (2004) Cutter Publishing, ISBN:978-0-578-01290-2.
- Wills, Clair, That Neutral Island page:London: Faber and Faber, ISBN:978-0-571-22105-9.
- Wood, Ian, Ireland during the Second World War (2002) page:London: Caxton ISBN:1-84067-418-0.
References or Citations
End of citations