This article has been donated to WikipediaThe Irish Willow was one of the few ships which maintained Irish trade during World War II. At the outbreak of World War II, known as "The Emergency", (3) (4) Ireland declared neutrality and became isolated as never before. (5) Although Ireland had a substantial food surplus, there were shortages of specific foods such as fruits, wheat and tea. There were very few Irish ships as shipping had been neglected (6) since independence. Foreign ships which had transported Irish cargoes, before the war, were soon unavailable.
No country had ever been more effectively blockaded because of the activities of belligerents and our lack of ships... — Taoiseach (Prime Minister) Éamon de Valera , Saint Patrick's Day address 17 March 1940The Otto, an Estonian ship, was in Cobh when the Republic of Estonia was suppressed by the USSR. In October 1941 trustees for the absent owners leased her to Irish Shipping. She was renamed Irish Willow, (7) She made 18 voyages to Saint John, New Brunswick, returning with wheat. She also exported food to Britain and imported coal. Initially Irish ships sailed in British convoys. In the light of experience they chose to sail alone, relying on their neutral markings. German respect for that neutrality varied from friendly to tragic.
ConstructionThe ship was built for the United States Shipping Board in Toledo, Ohio (Yard Number:143) by the Toledo Shipbuilding Company. (note1) A Standard WWI cargo ship, (8) she was laid down as War Flag, but named Lake Sunapee. (1A) She was launched on 28 December 1917, (9) (10) while World War I was still in progress. (11) She was a single deck vessel with a grain capacity of 130,000 cubic feet (3,681 m3) and bunker capacity of 2,009 GRT. She was 252 ft (76.81 m) long, 43 ft 5 in (13.2 m) wide and 18 ft 9 in (5.7 m) deep. (1B)
Early historyAs a Laker she was designed to navigate the canal locks bypassing Niagara Falls. (1C) Lake Sunapee served as a U.S. Army transport, based in Cardiff, Glamorgan, United Kingdom, bringing coal to France. (11A) She departed from Cardiff for New York City on 7 June 1919, (12) arrived 25 June and was decommissioned at Hoboken, New Jersey 3 July 1919. (11B) Little is known of her service in the years immediately following WWI, although it is recorded that she arrived at New York from the Pará on 29 May 1920. (13) She was laid up until 1923 when she was sold to W. J. Gray Jnr. of San Francisco and renamed Frank Lynch. She was built as a coal-fired steamship with a triple-expansion steam engine. In 1923 this was replaced with a Werkspoor diesel engine. (14) On 29 August 1929, the passenger ship San Juan collided with the tanker S.C.T. Dodd and sank with the loss of many lives. Frank Lynch, Munami and S.C.T. Dodd rescued the survivors. (15) In 1937, she was sold to the Greek company George D. Gratsos' Sons, (note2) who renamed her Nestor. (16) In 1938 she suffered a total engine failure and was towed to Rotterdam, (17) where she was converted back to a steamer. In 1939 she was sold to K Jurnas of Estonia and renamed Otto. (14A)
World War II
BackgroundThe Irish government had pursued a policy of self-sufficiency, (18) so international trade was discouraged and the mercantile marine (note3) ignored. At independence in 1923 there were 127 Irish ships, but by September 1939 there were only 56, including 7 which did not carry cargo. (19) Irish imports such as wheat, maize, timber and fertilizer were carried on foreign, mainly British, ships. (20) With the outbreak of hostilities, they were unavailable. (note4) Churchill explained "we need this tonnage for our own supply". (22) In November 1939, American ships were excluded from Irish waters by the neutrality act. (23) By the end of 1940, nine Irish ships (note5) as well as ten neutral foreign ships carrying Irish cargoes, some of which had been chartered by Irish companies, had been sunk by U-boats, the Luftwaffe or mines. (32) (33) (note6) Against this background, the government founded Irish Shipping (39) and sought ships which it could charter or purchase. (40) (41) The Irish Willow was one of those ships.
Soviet claimIn June 1940 the Soviet Union occupied the Baltic states and on 6 August 1940 Estonia was annexed as the Estonian Soviet Socialist Republic. Industry was nationalised and Estonian ships were instructed to go a Soviet port. There were several ships from the Baltic states in, or heading to, Irish ports. All ignored that instruction. Peter Kolts, a crewman of the Pirer, another Estonian ship at Dublin south quays, hoisted the hammer and sickle and prevented Captain Joseph Juriska from removing it. The Garda Síochána were called. Following a court appearance before Justice Michael Lennon the sailor spent a week in jail. (42) Ivan Maisky, the Soviet Union's ambassador to the United Kingdom, applied to the High Court in Dublin for possession of the ships Their owners could not be contacted. The Soviet case was supported by a letter from John Whelan Dulanty, the Irish High Commissioner in London, who explained that when the ships had been instructed to go immediately to the USSR three had been carrying cargoes destined for Ireland, that he had asked if they could first deliver their Irish cargo, and that Maisky had agreed on behalf of the Soviet Union, provided that the Irish government guaranteed that after discharging their cargo they would be given food sufficient for the journey to a Soviet port. A. K. Overend K.C., acting for Maisky, said that this established that his client was recognised by Ireland as "the proper person to give instruction to the ships", (43) and that his client was the only claimant. John McEvoy was the honorary consul (note7) of the Republic of Estonia in Dublin. (44) He opposed the Soviet claim along with Estonian representatives in Switzerland. Even though they lacked diplomatic status, the court recognised the right of Herbert Martinson, described as "an Estonian national, resident in Switzerland" to join with John McEvoy in vindicating the rights of the absent owners. (45) The court recognised John McEvoy and Herbert Martinson as trustees for the owners. The High Court considered five ships: three from Estonia, Otto, Piret and Mall, and two from Latvia, Ramava and Everoja. McEvoy acted for the various owners of the Estonian ships. On 16 May 1941 the High Court rejected the Soviet claim. The Soviet authorities appealed against the decision to the five-judge Supreme Court. On 3 July 1941 the appeal was unanimously dismissed with costs. (45A) The Soviet Union made a 'most emphatic' protest. (46) Martinson leased the three Estonian vessels to Irish Shipping for the duration of the war plus three months. The two Latvian ships transferred to the British registry and sailed under the Red Ensign. Ramava moved to Britain. Everoja remained in Ireland, (47) and was torpedoed and sunk on 3 November 1941 by U-203 (48) while in convoy SC-52 on passage from Canada to Dublin with 6,400 tons of wheat. (49) John McEvoy was acting at his own expense. There was no Estonian government to fund him. If he lost the case, the Soviets could have pursued him for their costs, probably bankrupting him. Fortunately,the Soviets lost and had to pay his legal expenses. The court further directed that he was to be reimbursed for his other expenses from the income earned by the Otto (Irish Willow). (17A) McEvoy's role was acknowledged by Estonia following its independence (the Singing Revolution), when the President of Estonia Toomas Hendrik Ilves said:
"... ... we are thankful that Ireland never recognised the illegal annexation of Estonia by the Soviet Union after the Second World War. We will never forget John McEvoy, Estonia’s honorary consul in Dublin from 1938 to 1960. Among other things, one of his good deeds was helping to protect the interests of the Estonian shipowners ..." (50)
Irish WillowOn October 1941, in Cobh, the Otto was chartered by Irish Shipping. She was brought to Dublin for extensive repairs. On 5 December 1941, she made her first voyage as the Irish Willow: She went from Cobh to Dublin under Captain G.R. Bryan, from Rathfarnam, previously captain of the City of Dublin. H. Cullen, previously of the Irish Elm, was first officer. H. Jurgenson was chief engineer; he was an Estonian national, and had been the chief engineer when she was the Otto (51). As some engine components were not available in Ireland, the repairs had to be completed in Canada. On 5 December she went on her first commercial voyage, under Captain R Shanks of Belfast, as the Irish Willow. She went to Troon for fuel and then joined convoy ON-47. The convoy departed on 15 December 1941. (52) Around this time, Irish crews were refusing to travel in convoy. The Irish Willow "lost" her convoy. (17B) She arrived in St John on 12 January 1942 and on 22 January loaded her cargo of wheat. Repairs delayed her a further two weeks. She was scheduled to return in convoy SC-68. (note8) Returning alone, a submarine was spotted on 3 February. (0) There was no contact. She unloaded her cargo of wheat in Waterford on 2 March and then went again for a further wheat cargo from St John for Waterford. (54) During the war, she completed 18 such voyages.
Encounter with U-753
Oil painting by Kenneth King: from the deck of U-753, signalling to Irish Willow "send master and ships papers" (National Maritime Museum of Ireland)
Rescuing the crew of Empire BreezeConvoy ON 122 (note10) left Liverpool on 15 August 1942. Ten days later, on 25 August 1942, when they were in the mid-Atlantic, the convoy was attacked by Wolfpack Lohs. (58) Four ships were torpedoed and sunk. (note11) The convoy retreated into a fogbank, with visibility less than 300 meters, probably saving further loss. The fog continued to thicken. (61) U-176 had hit the 7,457 ton Empire Breeze with two torpedoes. (62) (note12) An SOS was transmitted and acknowledged. The 47 (note13) surviving crew abandoned ship and took to their three lifeboats. (63) A fourth lifeboat was destroyed during launch. (63A) One crewman died (note14) The Empire Breeze remained afloat. The rescue ship Stockport was detailed to rescue them. The Irish Willow was 45 miles to the west, too far away to help. 24 hours after the attack the crew of the Empire Breeze were still in their lifeboats. Stockport had failed to locate them in the fog, so she left to rejoin the convoy. There were three radio officers. They had a portable radio transmitter in a lifeboat. Repeated SOS messages were not acknowledged. The Empire Breeze was still afloat. Captain Thomson and some of the crew re-boarded. The cook prepared hot meals. Joseph Brown, a radio officer, connected their portable radio with the ship's aerial and rebroadcast the SOS. This was heard and acknowledged by Belle Isle radio station in Canada. (66) The rescue tug HMS Frisky and the corvette HMCS Rosthern were sent to rescue the crew and salvage the Empire Breeze. They failed to locate her or the survivors. (67) A serious problem was that there had been fog for the previous few days, astronomical observations had not been taken, so no ship in the area knew their exact location. The various accounts of this event give different locations: www.wrecksite.eu (from the convoy report) (68) has 58°56'30?N 25°17'30?W. (69) Frank Forde's book (from the log of the Irish Willow) quotes 59°22'N 25°52'W. (70) 36 hours after the attack they sent another SOS. The Irish Willow heard this SOS, she responded and headed towards the scene. (71) The Irish Willow replied, asking how long they could hold out. Captain Thomson of the Empire Breeze estimated six hours. Captain Shanks of the Irish Willow replied “Coming to you – with you in about five hours”. The fog became denser and visibility reduced to zero. Rather than plotting locations, (dead reckoning) the Irish Willow was using direction finding equipment; (70A) she was travelling towards the SOS signal: It was dangerous for the Irish Willow. They knew the direction to take, but did not know the distance. Travelling in fog, they could collide with the Empire Breeze, or endanger survivors in the water. Extra look-outs were posted along her bow and whistles were sounded every two minutes. The repeating SOS messages could attract U-boats, seeking to “finish the job”, (72) and if such a U-boat found the Irish Willow at the scene, its attitude could be quite different to that encountered on 16 March. In dense fog (73) the survivors were located and rescued. The Irish Willow resumed her voyage to Waterford. As they rounded Hook Lighthouse they were met by the RNLI lifeboat Annie-Blanche-Smith from Dunmore East (73A) with an advance party of doctors and Red Cross volunteers. The Dunmore East Parish Hall had been converted into a reception center. A full team of Red Cross volunteers had arrived from Waterford. Hot meals and medical facilities were awaiting the survivors. It was decided to land the survivors at Dunmore East, while the Irish Willow continued to Waterford. Two were taken by ambulance to Waterford Infirmary with fever. (74) On 4 September 1942, the Munster Express, newspaper published an interview with Captain Thomson "We are very pleased to land in Eire, and we certainly could not have found a better landing".
James Brown and Laurence Burke photographed after signing-on the ''Irish Willow'' in 1943 (photo from 'Signal'
Post war serviceIn May 1946 the Irish Willow was returned to Egon Jurgenson. She was sold to Cia. de Vapores Veraguas and renamed Veraguas with a Panamanian registry. She continued to trade for a further 14 years. At the end of her 42 year career she was scrapped at Tamise, Belgium in July 1960. (75)
LegacyThe Irish Willow rescued the 47 survivors from the Empire Breeze. Throughout the war, Irish ships answered SOS calls and stopped to rescue, irrespective of nationality, and frequently – as in this instance – at risk to themselves. Ships in convoy were, usually, forbidden from stopping to rescue, lest they then became a target. (76) (77) The Empire Breeze crew were in their lifeboats when the Athelprince, with the convoy commodore aboard, had to alter course to avoid collision with the abandoned Empire Breeze, (78) but did not stop to rescue the crew. Irish ships rescued, at least, 534 seafarers during the war. (note16) Before the war, Irish Shipping Ltd did not exist. Its 15 ships were not under the Irish Flag. During the war, they imported more than a million tons of essential supplies: 712,000 tons of wheat; 178,000 tons of coal; 63,000 tons of phosphate (fertilizer); 24,000 tons of tobacco; 19,000 tons of newsprint; 10,000 tons of lumber; and over 100,000 tons of more than 500 types of other goods. (79) (This is in addition to the imports carried by other Irish ships) On 16 May 1945, a week after VE Day Éamon de Valera addressed the nation: (note17)
To the men of our Mercantile Marine who faced all the perils of the ocean to bring us essential supplies, the nation is profoundly grateful ... — Taoiseach (Prime Minister) Éamon de Valera , radio speech to the nation 16 May 1945In June 1946 a contract was signed with John Redhead and Sons, shipbuilders of South Shields to construct a new Irish Willow. (80)
- Burne, Lester H (2003). Richard Dean Burns, ed. Chronological History of U.S. Foreign Relations: 1932–1988 2. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-93916-4.
- Cleare, Brian; Boyce, Brian; Boyce, John; Coy, Leo (2013). Irish Shipping Lt. A Fleet History. Wexford: Rosslare Maritime Enthusiasts. ISBN 978-1-78280-177-1.
- Ferriter, Diarmaid (2006). What If? Alternative Views of Twentieth-Century Ireland. Gill & Macmillan. ISBN 978-0-7171-3990-3.
- Forde, Frank (1981). The Long Watch. Dublin: New Island Books (published 2000). ISBN 1-902602-42-0.
- Kennedy, Michael (2008). Guarding Neutral Ireland. Dublin: Four Courts Press. ISBN 978-1-84682-097-7.
- Kennedy, Walter (1998). Shipping in Dublin Port 1939–1945. Pentland Press. ISBN 1-85821-539-0.
- McShane, Mark (2012). Neutral Shores: Ireland and the Battle of the Atlantic. Cork: Mercier Press. ISBN 978-1-85635-934-4.
- Share, Bernard (1978). The Emergency. Dublin: Gill and Macmillan. ISBN 071710916X.
- Spong, H.C. (1982). Irish Shipping Ltd., 1941–1982. World Ship Society. ISBN 978-0-905617-20-6.
- Sweeney, Pat (2010). Liffey Ships and Shipbuilding. Mercier. ISBN 978-1-85635-685-5.
- Higgins, John, ed. (Autumn 1980). "Irish Willow". Signal 17 (4A). Newsletter Magazine of Irish Shipping Ltd
- "Zarine v. Owners, etc. S. S. Ramava, McEvoy & Ors. v. Owners, etc. S. S. Otto, McEvoy and Veldi v. Owners, etc. S. S. Piret and S. S. Mall, Eckert & Co. v. Owners, etc. S. S. Everoja". The American Journal of International Law, 36 (3A): 490–504. July 1942. doi:10.2307/2192676. Retrieved 30 May 2015.
- 1A^^ 1B^^ 1C^^ Cleare, page:60.
- 2^^Spong, page:28.
- 3A^^ Share, page:preface p.ix.
- 4A^^ Dáil debates, “Existence of National Emergency” (2 September 1939) 77:19–20: Government of Ireland
- 5^^Ferriter, “What If?” page:100.(Quoting Garvin) “Irish isolationism was a very powerful cultural sentiment at that time”
- 6^^Sweeney, page:204.
- 7^^Cleare, page:62.
- 8^^ Mariners List “WWI Standard ships, War C to War H”:
- 9^^Mooney, James L., ed., Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships, Volume 1 (1970) Government Printing Office page:32. isbn:9780160020193.
- 10^^Silverstone, Paul, The New Navy, 1883–1922 (May 2013) Routledge page:174. isbn:9781135865429.
- 11A^^ 11B^^ Mooney, James L., Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships, Volume 1 (1970) Government Printing Office page:32. isbn:9780160020193.
- 12^^ (Wednesday, 11 June 1919) (42123), col D-E: London: The Times page:18.
- 13^^ (Tuesday, 1 June 1920) (42425), col A-D: London: The Times page:20.
- 14A^^ Spong, page:29.
- 15^^ (Saturday, 31 August 1939) (45296), col E: London: The Times page:9.
- 16^^Spong, page:29.
- 17A^^ 17B^^ 17C^^ Cleare, page:62.
- 18^^Ferriter, Diarmaid, Judging DEV ((2007)) Dublin: Royal Irish Academy page:279. isbn:9781904890287.
- 19^^Forde, page:1.
- 20^^ Turn of the tide: an outline of Irish maritime history. Irish Shipping
- 21^^Spong, page:10.
- 22^^Sweeney, page:216.
- 23^^Burne, page:537.
- 24^^ http://lugnad.ie/munster/ lugnad.ie “Remember Munster | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime Hisory”
- 25^^ http://lugnad.ie/leukos/ lugnad.ie “Remember: Steam Trawler Leukos | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime History”
- 26^^ http://lugnad.ie/city-of-limerick/ lugnad.ie “Remember: City of Limerick | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime History”
- 27^^ http://lugnad.ie/meath/ lugnad.ie “Remember SS Meath | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime History”
- 28^^ http://lugnad.ie/luimneach/ Lugnad.ie 24 September 2013 “Remember – Luimneach | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime History”
- 29^^ http://lugnad.ie/kerry-head/ Lugnad.ie 12 September 2013 “Remember: Kerry Head | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime History”
- 30^^ “Remember-ardmore | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime History” (24 September 2013) Lugnad.ie
- 31^^ “Remember ILV Isolda | On-line Journal of Research on Irish Maritime History” (5 September 2013)
- 32^^Sweeney, page:217.
- 33^^MacGinty, Tom, The Irish Navy (1995) Tralee: The Kerryman page:57. isbn:0946277222.
- 34^^Sweeney, page:218.
- 35^^ http://www.uboat.net/allies/merchants/ships/324.html publisher='uboat.net', “27 May 1940 Uruguay (Argentinian Steam merchant) – Ships hit by German U-boats during WWII”
- 36^^ http://uboat.net/allies/merchants/418.html uboat.net “10 July 1940 Petsamo (Finnish Steam merchant) – Ships hit by German U-boats during WWII”
- 37^^ http://www.uboat.net/allies/merchants/ships/708.html uboat.net “8 December 1940 Penang (Finnish Sailing ship) – Ships hit by German U-boats during WWII”
- 38^^Duggan, page:111.
- 39^^ Gaffney, Maurice P October 1950 'The Irish Monthly' vol='78', issue='928' 475–483 http://www.jstor.org/stable/20516255 “Irish Shipping Limited: A Success Story: And a Moral”
- 40^^deCourcy Ireland, John, Ireland and the Irish in Maritime History (1986) Dún Laoghaire: Glendale Press page:356. isbn:0-907606-28-8.
- 41^^ (24 March 1941) The Irish Press page:1.
- 42^^Forde, page:42.
- 43^^Sweeney, page:225.
- 44^^ Estonian Embassy in Dublin
- 45A^^ http://www.jstor.org/stable/2192676 American Society of International Law The American Journal of International Law. vol 36 July 1942 3 490–504 doi="10.2307/2192676", "Eire High Court: Zarine v. Owners, etc. S. S. Ramava, McEvoy & Ors. v. Owners, etc. S. S. Otto, McEvoy and Veldi v. Owners, etc. S. S. Piret and S. S. Mall, Eckert & Co. v. Owners, etc. S. S. Everoja"
- 46^^ (9 August 1941)
- 47^^Sweeney, page:226.
- 48^^ http://www.uboat.net/allies/merchants/1196.html uboat.net “Everoja (British Steam merchant) – Ships hit by German U-boats during WWII”
- 49^^Walter Kennedy, page:45.
- 50^^ http://president.ee/en/official-duties/speeches/2625-president-of-the-republic-at-the-state-dinner-hosted-by-president-t-e-mary-mcaleese-and-dr-martin-mcaleese-14-april-2008-dublin-republic-of-ireland/index.html “President of the Republic at the State Dinner hosted by President T. E. Mary McAleese and Dr. Martin McAleese”. President.ee when='14 April 2008"
- 51^^Cleare, page:62.
- 52^^ http://convoyweb.org.uk/on/index.html?onz.php?convoy=47!~onzmain Cleare convoy database – ON convoys [lugite 53 63
- 54^^ “Irish Willow”. Signal (house magazine of Irish Shipping). War Time Fleet 17 (4): 7. Autumn 1980:
- 56^^ “Journal
- 57^^Forde, page:43,44.
- 58A^^ McShane, page:256.
- 62^^McShane, page:255.
- 65^^McShane, page:257.
- 66^^McShane, page:258.
- 67^^McShane, page:229.
- 68^^ http://warsailors.com/convoys/on122page2.html warsailors.com “Convoy ON 122, Commodore’s Report on Attacks”"
- 69^^ http://www.wrecksite.eu/wreck.aspx?15932 Wrecksite.eu “EMPIRE BREEZE CARGO SHIP 1941–1942 – WRECK WRAK EPAVE WRACK PECIO”"
- 70^^Forde, page:467.
- 71A^^ McShane, page:260.
- 72^^Forde, page:47.
- 73^^Cleare, page:64.
- 74A^^ McShane, page:263.
- 75^^Cleare, page:65.
- 76^^Gleichauf, Justin (2002). Unsung Sailors. Bluejacket Books, page:115. ISBN 978-1-55750-420-3..
- 77^^Sinclair, Andrew (2001). Blood & Kin: an empire saga. Sinclair-Stevenson, page:561. ISBN 978-0-9540476-3-4. ... or we’re sitting ducks. So we sail past all these drowning sailors, and they call up to us, and we must sail on. I remember one crying, “Taxi! Taxi!”. We didn’t stop.
- 78^^McShane, page:256.
- 79^^Andy Bielenberg; Raymond Ryan, An Economic History of Ireland Since Independence ( 20 May 2013) page:125.
- 80^^Cleare, page:101. Cleare, page:101.
End of citations End